Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms?

Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms?

Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

Advertisements

Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms The Vatican today opened the door for Catholics to use condoms more widely, sparking passionate theological discussion among his millions of followers across the world.

In an attempt to clear up the uncertainty produced by the publication of variously translated sections from a book of interviews with the pontiff over the weekend, his spokesperson used the book’s release to signal that condom usage is permissible as a lesser evil if there is a danger of HIV transmission.

The reaction to the declaration revealed the divisions among the Catholic church across Africa. Hardliners may have been caught off guard by the pope’s exaggerated remarks.

Advertisements

“Everyone is misinterpreting the Vatican,” said Matthew Ndagosa, archbishop of the Kaduna diocese in Nigeria, where Catholicism is flourishing. People have formed their own opinions on this subject and are distorting the words to fit.

“The Holy Father’s message was clear: there would be no policy change.” The church will continue to feel that using condoms indiscriminately fosters promiscuity and aggravates the issue.”

However, Boniface Lele, archbishop of the diocese of Mombasa in Kenya, where 30% of the population is Catholic, expressed satisfaction: he has been lobbying for a change in church policy on condoms, much to the chagrin of the Vatican. “In my diocese, I advise couples to use condoms if one or both of them is unwell.” It is beneficial for prevention.”

Gabriel Dolan, an Irish priest who works among the poor in Mombasa, called the church’s long-held stance on condom usage “an injustice to people in peril” in nations with a major Aids epidemic. “This is good news,” he stated. “I believe this is only the beginning.” A modest concession like this is like removing a brick from the Berlin Wall.”

According to the German original and English version of journalist Peter Seewald’s book, Light of the World, the use of a condom by an HIV-positive male prostitute may be a good thing because it would indicate a first step toward accepting responsibility. In the Italian version, however, the term for a female prostitute was used.

Several observers, notably conservatives, seized on the pope’s rare example to argue that he was not authorizing a shift in his church’s stance to artificial contraception. It was suggested that by alluding to gay intercourse, in which condoms are not used for contraception, he was perpetuating the restriction on their use in heterosexual relationships.

However, at a press conference in the Vatican to mark the publication of the book, his spokesperson, Father Federico Lombardi, stated that he had discussed the topic with the pope on Sunday. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

“I personally questioned the Pope if there was a big, significant problem in the masculine over the feminine,” Lombardi stated. “He said ‘no.'”

“It’s the first step of taking responsibility, of considering the danger of the life of somebody with whom you have a relationship,” Lombardi added. This applies whether you are a guy, a woman, or a transgender.”

The book, as various experts have pointed out, cannot change doctrine. However, Lombardi’s statements reveal that the pope views condom use as a lesser evil in situations when there is a risk of HIV transmission.

The Catholic prohibition on using condoms or any other contraceptive device remains in effect. Cardinal Rino Fisichella, one of the pope’s most senior officials, told a press conference that condoms were “intrinsically an evil.”

The pope’s remarks do not diminish his stance that abstinence and faithfulness are more crucial in the battle against Aids.

Seewald reiterates in his book that condoms are “not actually the method to cope with the evil of HIV infection.” When asked whether his religion is opposed to their usage in principle, he delivers a response that falls far short of a direct statement.

“Of course, it does not see it as a genuine or moral answer, but in this or that situation, there may be a beginning step in a movement toward a better, more human way of experiencing sexuality in the goal of lowering the danger of infection.”

The change appears to have caught some of his most senior staff off guard. When asked by the website of the US-based National Catholic Register if the pope’s comments indicated that condoms were permitted in some instances, Cardinal Raymond Burke said flatly: “No, it’s not.”

“[The pope] has let the genie out of the bottle,” said Elena Curti, deputy editor of the Catholic weekly The Tablet. It’s quite tough to put it back in after that. Allowing this glimmer of light in, despite his cautious phrasing, helps open up the argument.” Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

The Terrence Higgins Trust, an HIV organization, was overjoyed by the news. “It does represent a significant departure in terms of what the Vatican previously stated,” said Genevieve Edwards, the trust’s communications director. “His remarks are wide enough to allow anyone to interpret them as they see fit.”

However, John Smeaton, a Catholic and the director of the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child, denied any policy change. “Pope Benedict, like all Catholics, is bound by the church’s magisterium, which he announces in Caritas in veritate,” he wrote on his blog. “He’s not likely to support a shift in that teaching in a year’s time in an interview with a journalist – and he doesn’t.”

Father Tim Finigan, a renowned Catholic blogger, welcomed the move but cautioned: “I must express my personal perspective to the holy father’s statements on Aids and condoms.” It would be similar to Sergeant Wilson in Dad’s Army: ‘Do you think that’s sensible, sir?’ We know that mass condom distribution to combat the HIV/AIDS epidemic has failed in practice.”

Today, one hundred and fifteen cardinals begin the process of selecting Pope John Paul II’s successor. Given that all but two of these cardinals were appointed during John Paul II’s 27-year pontificate, it is widely assumed that John Paul’s successor will share his views on homosexuality being “disordered,” same-sex marriage being a “evil,” and all forms of artificial contraception being inherently sinful and part of Western society’s “culture of death.” Even when used to prevent disease transmission, the use of a condom constitutes a deadly sin, the greatest category of sin in the Catholic church. Official doctrine holds that if a Catholic uses a condom while knowing of the church’s position, unless they confess their sin and do penance, they place themselves beyond the church’s redeeming grace. To put it another way, use a condom and go to hell.

John Paul II’s image will also linger greatly over his successor. Mourners in St. Peter’s Square established a John Paul II cult. In a requiem liturgy for the late Pope, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (a conservative seen as a possible candidate to become the next Pope) referred to him as John Paul the Great, an honor bestowed only on two of his predecessors (Leo the Great and Gregory the Great, both of whom occupied the See of St Peter in late antiquity). John Paul “the Great” is destined to join Mother Theresa of Calcutta in becoming a candidate for canonisation within years of his death, having revealed his hardline views on contraception and condoms.

Obituaries in the broadcast media and many newspapers concentrated on the perceived triumphs of John Paul II’s long pontificate: his involvement in the fall of communism, his relentless travels, his fortitude in the face of physical discomfort, and his advocacy for the poor. World leaders choose whatever features of his rule they wanted to be associated with. As a result, US President George W. Bush lionized John Paul’s hostility to communism and abortion while ignoring the late Pope’s unwavering opposition to death punishment and both Iraq wars. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

However, outspoken criticism of the late Pope has also been leveled, with many concentrating on his resistance to the use of condoms not only for birth control, but also to combat HIV transmission.

Conservative Catholic views on condoms are not meant to be unkind. Condoms, according to traditional Catholics, are improper to use, even as a preventative measure against sickness, because they impede pregnancy. Catholics believe that life, from conception to death, is holy. Only God has the power to end life. It is also worth remembering that Pope John Paul II spoke out against HIV prejudice, and Catholic AIDS ministries all around the globe put his words into action.

However, some conservative Catholics have used pseudo-scientific reasons to argue against the use of condoms as a way of HIV prevention. According to a recent BBC Panorama broadcast, some prominent Catholic clergy not only maintained that condoms were theologically unsound, but that they were also distributing incorrect information about the dependability and safety of condoms.

Thousands, if not millions, of new HIV infections have therefore been linked to the Catholic church’s, and particularly the late pontiff’s, unwavering resistance to condom use. There have even been calls for women who refused to use condoms on religious reasons and were infected with HIV by their spouses to be recognized as Catholic martyrs.

Although HIV campaigners and their friends in the liberal press have frequently led this critique, it has received backing from unexpected sources. Ferdinand Mount, a former adviser to Margaret Thatcher, was stung by a post by fellow Daily Telegraph columnist, the neo-conservative Mark Steyn, praising the Pope’s “culture of life,” to use his column to expose John Paul II’s flaws on condoms, birth control, and homosexuality. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

The role of the Catholic church in providing HIV care and treatment has often been overlooked in the media’s assessment of the late Pope and conjecture about his performance. Regardless of who is elected Pope, the Catholic Church will continue to play this function.

CAFOD, a Catholic charity organization based in the United Kingdom, sponsors HIV care, education, and prevention programs in Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe, and South America. Its publication, “HIV and AIDS: the Facts,” is carefully phrased and advocates for an ABC approach of HIV prevention. CAFOD condemns disinformation concerning condom dependability, whether it says that condoms are 100% dependable or that condoms contain tiny holes in them through which HIV can transmit.

Catholic religious and teaching organizations play a vital role in HIV treatment efforts across the world, such as Sister Mary Virginia Annel’s CONTRASIDA project in El Salvador, which administers antiretroviral medicine.

HIV prevention activity frequently coexists alongside treatment and care activities. Traditional Catholic doctrine is very vital. However, there is evidence that some Catholic clergy working on the front lines of HIV care delivery are taking a more pragmatic approach. Dr. Peter Piot, the head of UNAIDS and a Catholic, presented an example of such pragmatism during a press conference in London before to the 2004 International AIDS Conference. He told of encountering Catholic nuns in southern Africa who were handing out condoms to women. When Dr Piot inquired how they could give condoms against official Vatican teaching, one of the nuns said, “Rome is a long way away.”

Such an attitude would astound many devout Catholics and pastors. Indeed, the hardline Catholic Action pressure organization recently labeled donating to CAFOD a “sin” due of its liberal stance on condoms and contraception. The major African contenders for the Pope all have a conservative view of Catholic doctrine on sexuality and condoms, even when used to prevent HIV transmission. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

However, there are schisms within the Catholic hierarchy. The South African Catholic Bishops Conference released an HIV statement in 2001 that advocated for the use of condoms by discordant couples. Cardinal Godfried Danneels, archbishop of Brussels and Mechelen, is a liberal who is considered an outside contender for the Papacy. He added that if an HIV-positive individual wanted to continue sexual activity, they should use condoms to avoid infecting others and violating the commandment “Thou shall not murder.”

His remarks may reflect mainstream Catholic thought in Europe. “It appears to me that if individuals are bent on intercourse, they at least have a responsibility of avoiding passing on sickness and death, even if the only feasible means to them is the use of a condom,” stated the late cardinal Basil Hume, standing by his assistant bishop of East London, Victor Guazzelli. This seemed to me to be common sense.” Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor, Basil Hume’s successor as Archbishop of Westminster, is said to have similar beliefs. This should come as no surprise, given the Western church’s stance on contraception. Few western Catholics would confess to their parish priest their use of contraception, and even fewer priests would impose a penance for using the contraceptive pill. According to estimates, 75% of married Catholics in wealthier nations utilize contraception, and Italy has the lowest birth rate in the European Union.

There is considerable support among the Catholic laity for the use of condoms to prevent the transmission of HIV. Given that the vast majority of Western Catholics happily ignore official Catholic teachings on birth control, it is hardly surprising that an increasing number of vocal and confident believers are willing to challenge the Vatican on other issues. Condoms4Life is one such organization, which developed out of Catholics for a Free Choice, a pro-choice lobbying group in the United States. Condoms4Life was founded in response to the Vatican’s assertion that condom promotion contributed to the spread of HIV rather than restricting transmission. The organization’s message is simple: condoms save lives, and a good Catholic would use a condom to avoid disease transmission. It urges Catholics to contact their bishops, emphasizing the ethical and health-promoting benefits of condoms. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

Official sexual teachings are also being questioned. We Are the Church, a UK-based organization, contends that official Catholic doctrine does not accept modern understanding about human sexuality, and that celibacy should be an option, not a requirement. Enda McDonagh, retired professor of moral theology at Maynooth College in Dublin, is one theologian who emphasizes the importance of committed same-sex partnerships.

The Catholic church is the western world’s oldest institution. Tradition in Catholicism is more than just charming and scenic; it is a guiding element deciding theology and authority. To defend their viewpoint, supporters of authentic Catholic doctrine on condoms and sexuality point to centuries of apparent doctrinal and moral consistency. They contend that the church cannot adapt simply to reflect current secular norms, even if these doctrines on the role of women in the church, clerical celibacy, abortion, and sexuality appear out of sync.

However, reading some church history reveals how malleable the church is, and that traditional beliefs do not have the antiquity that is supposed. Women were deacons in the early Latin church, clerical celibacy was not enforced in Catholic Chistendom until the eleventh century, contraception and abortion until the 40th day of pregnancy were permissible until the Vatican Council of 1870, and an American scholar of the early church has even suggested that a form of same-sex blessing existed in early ordinals.

As a result, the Catholic church’s doctrines and teachings are subject to change. It is not impossible that the church’s attitude on condoms, as well as many other matters concerning human sexuality and reproduction, may alter in the near future. Can Catholic Married Couples Use Condoms

But, will it happen under the next Pope? Anyone who saw the television displays of popular sadness mourning for John Paul II throughout the world, or who heard or read the eulogies provided in his memory, may be forgiven for thinking that he left a church well-positioned to tackle the problems of the early twenty-first century. Catholicism, in truth, is in crisis. Mass attendance dropped considerably during John Paul II’s rule, even in his own Poland, which, like the rest of Europe and North America, is severely short of priests. Child abuse scandals have devastated American Catholicism. The church in Latin America is under attack from evangelical protestantism, which has taken so many souls that it has been dubbed the “Second Reformation.” Attendance at mass and vocations are high in Africa and Asia, but Islam offers a problem, demanding a hardline response. AIDS, on the other hand, puts into doubt contraceptive teachings in Africa.

Will a John Paul II-style pope restore the fortunes of the world’s largest religion? Will the cardinals meeting in the Sistine Chapel choose change? There has recently been precedence. After a 19-year pontificate, conservative Pope Pius XII (a hero of John Paul II and just beatified by him) died in 1959. His successor, John XXIII, ruled for barely five years, but by convening the Second Vatican Council, he brought the Catholic church into the twentieth century. Perhaps the next successor to St Peter will institute changes to better prepare the church for the difficulties of the twenty-first century.

Advertisements

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*